![]() ![]() A town crier raps the news with all the bravado but none of the skill of a Hamilton song. ![]() Like the worst modernizations, Cinderella feels like the result of out-of-touch executives trying to identify the hip new thing. They’re all just loosely appropriate for the moment at hand. Nothing thematically links any of the songs that were chosen to knit this film into a musical an Ed Sheeran number co-exists on the soundtrack with an Earth, Wind & Fire anthem. The hardworking townspeople perform Janet Jackson’s “Rhythm Nation” because, well, they work in rhythm, I suppose. The wicked stepmother belts out “Material Girl,” by Madonna, because she’s a bit of a material girl (living, of course, in a material world). Prince Robert sings “Somebody to Love,” by Queen, because he’s looking for somebody to love. In case any ensemble member’s motivations aren’t readily apparent, each gets a pop song that lays out exactly what they’re thinking. ![]() This is not to say that any other character is more fully developed. What should be a triumphant piece of storytelling renovation instead comes across as deeply cynical, given the character’s lack of depth. The character may embody a new value system-one that refutes the stuffy traditionalism of past adaptations-but she’s as one-dimensional as ever. Of course, there’s nothing wrong with giving her greater aspirations than marrying into royalty, but the movie forgets to add anything beyond these career goals. No longer a mere prisoner of her nasty stepmother (Idina Menzel) awaiting salvation at the hands of her beloved prince, this Cinderella is a strong, business-minded dressmaker who wants to work in high fashion. Read: Cinderella, and the virtues of being old-fashionedĪnd then there’s Cinderella herself (Camila Cabello). Why is Robert in line to inherit the throne when his sister, Princess Gwen (Tallulah Greive), is the one pestering her dad about tax reform and public-works projects? Why should the grumpy king make all the decisions when his wife is far more levelheaded? The setting is little more than an opportunity for Cannon, who wrote the Pitch Perfect movies and directed the uproariously sweet Blockers, to dole out easy criticisms of feudalism in the name of female agency. The film, out on Amazon Prime Video this Friday, is a mess.ĭespite the modern dialogue and contemporary soundtrack, Cinderella is set in some vaguely defined, medieval fantasy kingdom ruled by a surly king (played by Pierce Brosnan), his wise queen (Minnie Driver), and their ne’er-do-well son, Prince Robert (Nicholas Galitzine). It’s a loud, brassy update that mixes in pop songs, self-referential jokes, and a thuddingly obvious message of empowerment. Her entire project is apparently based on an idea from James Corden, who appears as one of Cinderella’s helpful mouse friends. Kay Cannon, the latest director to adapt Charles Perrault’s story, certainly seems to think so. Can she ever actually be three-dimensional? She embodies the moral principle that goodness-along with some fancy slippers and Prince Charming’s hand in marriage-is its own reward. Cinderella is the world’s most famous underdog, but she’s also more of a plot vehicle than a deep character. What would a modern Cinderella look like? The classic fairy tale has been told so many times on film, always following the same basic arc: A charming girl, who is forced into servitude by her mean stepmother and wishes to go to a ball, ultimately gets what she wants with the help of three mice and a magic fairy. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |